54. Introduction - Scott D. Bates
55. The Role of Academe - Todd Stewart
1. National Strategy for Homeland Security, Office of Homeland Security, White House, July 2002.
2. Ibid.
3. S. Jaschik, ‘‘Homeland Security and the American Campus,’’
Priorities, Association of Governing Boards, No. 23 (Spring 2004).
4. National Research Council, ‘‘Making the Nation Safer: The Role of
Science and Technology in Countering Terrorism’’ (Washington, D.C.:
National Academy Press, 2002).
5. Ibid.
6. B. S. Bloom, Taxonomy of Educational Objectives: The Classification
of Educational Objectives (New York: McKay, 1965).
7. E. J. Simpson, ‘‘The Classification of Educational Objectives in the
Psychomotor Domain,’’ in The Psychomotor Domain, Vol. 3, (Washington,
DC: Gryphon House, 1972), pp. 43–56.
8. www.training.fema.gov/emiweb/edu/.
9. National Research Council, ‘‘Making the Nation Safer.’’
10. www.homelandsecurity.osu.edu/NACHS.
11. National Research Council, ‘‘Making the Nation Safer.’’
56. The Future of HLS Education - Joseph Vorbach
1. For an overview of the ongoing transformation in DOD, see
Arthur K. Cebrowski, ‘‘Transformation and the Changing Character of
War,’’ Officer (July–August 2004).
2. Richard H. Ullman, ‘‘Redefining Security,’’ International Security 8:1 (Summer 1983): 129.
3. Ibid., p. 133.
4. See, e.g.: Netta Crawford, ‘‘Once and Future Security Studies,’’
Security Studies 1 (Winter 1991). Stephen M. Walt, ‘‘The Renaissance of
Security Studies,’’ International Studies Quarterly 35 (June 1991).
Helga Haftendorn, ‘‘The Security Puzzle,’’ International Studies
Quarterly 35 (March 1991). Joseph S. Nye, Jr., and Sean M. Lynn-Jones,
‘‘International Security Studies: A Report of a Conference on the State
of the Field,’’ International Security 12:4 (Spring 1988): 5–27. Peter
Andreas and Richard Price, ‘‘From Warfighting to Crime Fighting:
Transforming the American National Security State,’’ International
Studies Review 3:3 (Fall 2001): 31. Andreas and Price note a ‘‘growing
gap between traditional security concepts and paradigms and the
contemporary practice of security.’’
5. U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO), ‘‘Drug Control: Assets DOD
Contributes to Reducing the Illegal Drug Supply Have Declined,’’
GAO/NSIAD-00-9 (21 December 1999). This report confronts the issue
faced by a defense department with a continually widening array of
obligations related to nontraditional threats.
6. See Lawrence Freedman, ‘‘International Security: Changing Targets,’’
Foreign Policy (Spring 1998): 53. Freedman articulated the concern of
traditionalists: ‘‘Once anything that generates anxiety or threatens
the quality of life in some respect becomes labeled a ‘security
problem’ the field risks losing all focus.’’
7. See Marc A. Levy, ‘‘Is the Environment a National Security Threat?’’
International Security 20:2 (Fall 1995). See also Erik K. Stern, ‘‘The
Case for Comprehensive Security,’’ in Daniel H. Deudney and Richard A.
Matthew (eds.), Contested Grounds: Security and Conflict in the New
Environmental Politics (Albany: State University of New York Press,
1999), pp. 135–142.
8. See, e.g., Peter J. Katzenstein, The Culture of National Security:
Norms and Identity in World Politics (New York: Columbia University
Press, 1996). See also Keith Krause and Michael C.Williams (eds.),
Critical Security Studies: Concepts and Cases (Minneapolis: University
of Minnesota Press, 1997).
9. Richard K. Betts, ‘‘Should Strategic Studies Survive,’’ World Politics 50 (October 1997): 9.
10. Although the term homeland security seems to be associated with the
United States since 9/11, the lessons learned from the efforts of other
nations must be a component of a robust program of strategic studies in
homeland security.
11. Fiscal realities may require the augmentation of a full residential
program with a combination of distance-learning approaches, a
relaxation of residential requirements. A shorter ‘‘command and staff’’
program attended by midlevel leaders may be an appropriate, albeit
incremental, strategy.
12. One example of an effort to institute strategic renewal in a public
organization is the U.S. Coast Guard’s Evergreen Project, which focuses
on scenario-based planning and the ability to know, shape, create,
manage, and position an organization for future success.
13. DHS has developed prototype courses that bring mid- and
senior-level leaders together for, among other things, team building
and analysis of shared challenges. These programs should be expanded
and established more formally.
14. Doing so will be consistent with ‘‘DHS Strategic Plan—Securing Our
Homeland,’’ which includes the strategic goal of organizational
excellence and sets out to create a leadership development curriculum
for all department executive managers and supervisors.
15. For example, the Web sites of the National Academic Consortium for Homeland Security at http://homelandsecurity.osu.edu/NACHS/ and the Northern Command Homeland Security/Defense Education Consortium at www.hsdec.org/ (accessed 13 September 2004).
16. See, e.g., Center for Unconventional Security Affairs at the University of California-Irvine, www.cusa.uci.edu (accessed 14 September 2004); Matthew B. Ridgway Center for International Security Studies at the University of Pittsburgh, www.umc.pitt.edu/media/pcc020211/ridgwayctr.html (accessed 14 September 2004); and Transnational Crime and Corruption Center at American University, www.american.edu/traccc/ (accessed 13 September 2004).
17. 6 USC 188, Public Law 107–296, 25 November 2002, Sec. 308. Conduct
of research, development, demonstration, testing, and evaluation. (c)
Discretion of secretary.—The Secretary shall have the discretion to
establish such centers and to consider additional criteria as necessary
to meet the evolving needs of homeland security.’’
18. See David McIntyre, Ph.D., Deputy Director of ANSER Institute for
Homeland Security, ‘‘Education for Homeland Security—The Critical
Need,’’ ETS News (Winter 2002—2003), at www.homelandsecurity.org/hlscommentary/Education_for_Homeland_Security.htm
(accessed 29 August 2004). Few civilians grasp the breadth and
sophistication of the U.S. military education program. In contrast to
the lack of a nationally accredited or DHS-administered advanced
homeland security education program, the U.S. war colleges grant
master’s degrees and require graduate-level work. The most promising
military officers frequently receive up to three years of full-time
resident attendance in civilian master’s or Ph.D. programs. The average
midlevel army officer working on plans and budgets in the Pentagon has
three to five equivalent years of postgraduate study—a Ph.D. program’s
worth of postgraduate schooling in his field. A general devotes a
quarter of his career to formal preparation for his position.
19. The nine-month State Department Senior Service seminar, established
by President Eisenhower in 1958 and constructed on an interagency
teamwork model, should also be considered among the useful examples
from the Cold War period.
20. See Captain Robert G. Ross and Commander Peyton M. Coleman, ‘‘The
Way Forward: Education and Jointness in Homeland Security—Learning from
the Department of Defense,’’ Journal of Homeland Security (May 2003),
(accessed
13 September 2004). See also Michael E. Doyle and Greg Stump, ‘‘Why We
Need a Homeland Security University,’’ Homeland Defense Journal
(December 2003): 22–7.
57. Decision Models for Emergency Response Planning - Richard C. Larson
1.
Philip M. Morse and George E. Kimball, Methods of Operations Research
(Cambridge, Mass.: Technology Press, 1951); republished by Saul I. Gass
(ed.) (New York: Dover, 2003).
2. David Lionardt, ‘‘Incremental Analysis, with Two Yards to Go,’’ New York Times (1 February 2004). See also http://espn.go.com/nfl/columns/garber_greg/1453717.html.
3. John M. Barry, The Great Influenza: The Epic Story of the 1918 Pandemic (New York: Viking Penguin, 2004).
4. Alfred Blumstein et al., Task Force Report: Science and Technology—A
Report to the President’s Commission on Law Enforcement and
Administration of Justice, Prepared by the Institute for Defense
Analyses (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967).
5. Richard C. Larson, ‘‘Improving the Effectiveness of New York City’s
911,’’ in A. W. Drake, R. L. Keeney, and P. M. Morse (eds.), Analysis
of Public Systems (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 1972).
6. C. Schaack and R. C. Larson, ‘‘An N Server Cutoff Priority Queue,’’
Operations Research 34:2 (1986): 257–66. C. Schaack and R. C. Larson,.
‘‘An N Server Cutoff Priority Queue Where Arriving Customers Request a
Random Number of Servers,’’ Management Science 35:5 (1989): 614–34. In
the following, we show how this would work with data from the Hartford,
Connecticut, police department: Stephen R. Sacks, Richard C. Larson,
and Christian Schaack, ‘‘Minimizing the Cost of Dispatch Delays by
Holding Patrol Cars in Reserve,’’ Journal of Quantitative Criminology
9:2 (1993): 203–24.
7. Richard C. Larson, Urban Police Patrol Analysis (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1972).
8. Richard C. Larson, ‘‘Public Sector Operations Research: A Personal
Perspective,’’ Operations Research 50:1 (2002): 135–45.
9. Richard C. Larson, ‘‘A Hypercube Queuing Modeling for Facility
Location and Redistricting in Urban Emergency Services,’’ Journal of
Computers and Operations Research 1:1 (1974): 67–95. Richard C. Larson,
‘‘Approximating the Performance of Urban Emergency Service Systems,’’
Operations Research 23:5 (1975): 845–68.
10. Richard C. Larson and E. Franck, ‘‘Evaluating Dispatching
Consequences of Automatic Vehicle Location in Emergency Services,’’
Journal of Computers and Operations Research 5 (1978): 11–30.
11. Richard C. Larson, ‘‘Illustrative Police Sector Redesign in
District 4 in Boston,’’ Urban Analysis 1:1 (1974): 51–91.
12. Richard C. Larson, ‘‘Measuring the Response Patterns of New York
City Police Patrol Cars.’’ New York City Rand Institute R-673-NYC/HUD
(1971).
13. Richard C. Larson and T. Rich, ‘‘Travel Time Analysis of New York City Police Patrol Cars,’’ Interfaces 17:2 (1987): 15–20.
14. M. Brandeau and R. C. Larson, ‘‘Extending and Applying the
Hypercube Queuing Model to Deploy Ambulances in Boston,’’ in A. Swersey
and E. Ignall (eds.), Delivery of Urban Services (New York: North
Holland Press, 1986).
15. Stephen R. Sacks and Shirley Grief, ‘‘Orlando Magic: Efficient
Design of Police Patrol Districts,’’ OR/MS Today 21:1 (February 1994).
16. Richard C. Larson, ‘‘Hypercube Queuing Model,’’ in Saul I. Gass and
Carl M. Harris (eds.), Encyclopedia of Operations Research and
Management Science (Boston, Mass.: Kluwer, 2001): 373–7.
17. L. V. Green and P. J. Kolesar, ‘‘Applying Management Science to
Emergency Response Systems: Lessons from the Past,’’ Management Science
50:8 (August 2004): 1001–14. P. Kolesar, ‘‘Ten Years of Research on the
Logistics of Urban Emergency Services,’’ in J. P. Brans (ed.),
Operational Research 1981 (New York: North Holland Press, 1982). P.
Kolesar and A. Swersey, ‘‘The Deployment of Urban Emergency Units: A
Survey,’’ TIMS Studies in Management Science 22 (1985).
18. P. Kolesar and W. E. Walker, ‘‘An Algorithm for the Dynamic
Relocation of Fire Companies,’’ Operations Research 22:2 (March–April
1974): 249–74. W. Walker, J. Chaiken, and E. Ignall (eds.), Fire
Department Deployment Analysis (New York: North Holland Press, 1979).
19. McKinsey Report, Increasing FDNY’s Preparedness. See www.ci.nyc.ny.us/html/fdny/html/mck_report/index.shtml.
20. Peter Kolesar, personal communication, 10 and 17 August 2004.
21. Michael Metzger, ‘‘Formulating Earthquake Response Models in
Iran.’’ Master’s thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (2004).
22. Richard C. Larson and A. R. Odoni, Urban Operations Research (Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice Hall, 1981).
23. P. E. Taylor and S. J. Huxley, ‘‘A Break from Tradition for San
Francisco Police: Patrol Officer Scheduling Using an Optimization-Based
Decision Support System,’’ Interfaces 19:1 (1989): 4–24.
24. Rajan Batta and Samuel S. Chiu, ‘‘Optimal Obnoxious Paths on a
Network: Transportation of Hazardous Materials,’’ Operations Research
36:1 (1988): 4–92. Oded Berman, Z. Drezner, and G. Wesolowsky, ‘‘A
Routing and Location on a Network with Hazardous Threats,’’ Journal of
the Operational Research Society 51 (2000): 1093–9. Oded Berman, V.
Verter, and Y. Bahar, ‘‘Designing Emergency Response Networks for
Hazardous Materials Transportation,’’ working paper, Rotman School of
Management, University of Toronto (2004). Ram Gopalan, Krishna S.
Kolluri, Rajan Batta, and Mark H. Karwin, ‘‘Modeling Equity of Risk in
the Transportation of Hazardous Materials,’’ Operations Research 38:6
(1990): 961–73. Honghua Jin, Rajan Batta, and Mark H. Karwin, ‘‘On the
Analysis of Two Models for Transporting Hazardous Materials,’’
Operations Research 44:5 (1996): 710–23.
25. Lawrence M. Wein and Edward H. Kaplan, ‘‘Unready for Anthrax,’’ Washington Post (28 July 2003): A21.
26. Lawrence M. Wein, David L. Craft, and Edward H. Kaplan, ‘‘Emergency
Response to an Anthrax Attack,’’ PNAS 100:7 (1 April 2003): 4347–51.
27. Edward H. Kaplan, William J. Bicknell, and Lawrence M. Wein, ‘‘The
Citizen as First Responder.’’ Fox News (13 August 2003). See www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,94665,00.html.
28. United States Postal Service, ‘‘U.S. Postal Service May Deliver
Medicine in the Event of a Catastrophic Incident.’’ News release no.
04-015 (18 February 2004).
29. Edward H. Kaplan, David L. Craft, and Lawrence M. Wein, ‘‘Emergency
Response to a Smallpox Attack: The Case for Mass Vaccination,’’ PNAS
99:16 (6 August 2002): 10935–40.
30. L. V. Green, ‘‘How Many Hospital Beds? Inquiry (Winter 2002–2003):
400–12. L. V. Green, ‘‘Capacity Planning in Hospitals,’’ in Handbook of
Operations Research/ Management Science Applications in Health Care
(New York: Kluwer Academic, 2004).
31. D. M. Bravata, K. McDonald, D. K. Owens, E. Wilhelm, M. L.
Brandeau, G. S. Zaric, J.-E. C. Holty, H. Liu, and V. Sundaram,
Regionalization of Bioterrorism Preparedness and Response (Evidence
Report/Technology Assessment) (Rockville, Md.: Agency for Healthcare
Research and Quality, 2003). G. S. Zaric, M. L. Brandeau, D. M.
Bravata, J.-E. C. Holty, E. R. Wilhelm, K. M. McDonald, and D. K.
Owens, ‘‘Modeling the Logistics of Response to Anthrax Bioterrorism,’’
working paper, Stanford University (2004).
32. Qiang Gong, Arun Jotshi, and Rajan Batta, ‘‘Dispatching/Routing of
Emergency Vehicles in a Disaster Environment Using Data Fusion
Concepts,’’ Proceedings of the International Data Fusion Conference,
Stockholm (June 2004).
33. Oded Berman and A. Gavious. ‘‘Location of Bioterror Response
Facilities: A Game between State and Terrorist,’’ working paper, Rotman
School of Management, University of Toronto (2004).
34. B. Thengvall, J. Bard, and G. Yu, ‘‘Multiple Fleet Aircraft
Schedule Recovery Following Hub Closures,’’ Transportation Research,
Part A 35 (2001): 289–308. B. Thengvall, J. F. Bard, and G. Yu,
‘‘Balancing User Preferences for Aircraft Recovery during Airline
Irregular Operations,’’ IIE Transactions on Operations Engineering 32
(2000): 181–93. G. Yu, M. Arguello, M. Song, S. McCowan, and A. White,
‘‘A New Era for Crew Recovery at Continental Airlines,’’ Interfaces
33:1 (2003): 5–22.
35. See www.nyc.gov/html/oem/html/response/calms.html.
36. See www.dhs.gov/dhspublic/display?content¼3259 (link not current).
37. See www3.ccps.virginia.edu/career_prospects/briefs/E-J/EmergencyManage.html (link not current).
|